Self-Defense, Not ‘Stuff’ Defense
Self-Defense, Not ‘Stuff’ Defense
By Kevin Michalowski // 11/12/2018
By Kevin Michalowski // 11/12/2018
Do not use your gun for anything except defense against an imminent deadly threat.The goal of true self-defense is to create enough dysfunction in your attacker that you can escape safely. If you can escape without firing a shot, you should make every effort to do so. This video shows one man shooting another man over a $16 hatchet. The shooter was “defending” his property, as he believed the man he shot was shoplifting a hatchet.
The local district attorney filed charges against the shooter. The case will very likely go to trial and, from what we see on the video, it may not go well for the shooter. Unless further information comes out, the shooting does not appear justified.
Yes, theft is frustrating. Yes, we should have the right to defend our property. But the courts have ruled that any use of force must be “objectively reasonable.” It is unreasonable to kill a person over the attempted theft of a $16 hatchet.
Now, if the shoplifter were attempting to use that stolen hatchet to kill someone, then the game changes. But because we are the good guys, our actions must be in reaction to a deadly threat. That means we have to keep our distance and wait to see such a threat. If the threat does not materialize, you can’t use force.
You may disagree with this, but you will be voicing that disagreement to a judge and jury. We, as responsibly armed Americans, cannot be mistaken in our deadly force decision-making. We must do the right thing. Using deadly force to stop shoplifting is not the right thing. Know the laws of your jurisdiction. Reserve deadly force as the final option in your personal-protection plan.
Is Someone Trying to Kill You?
This is the overriding question in the use of deadly force. Do you reasonably believe that someone is trying to kill you? Can you articulate this reasonable belief to other reasonable people? Would those people with the same information you had do the same thing? These are the pivotal questions in determining if deadly force is justified.
The local district attorney filed charges against the shooter. The case will very likely go to trial and, from what we see on the video, it may not go well for the shooter. Unless further information comes out, the shooting does not appear justified.
Yes, theft is frustrating. Yes, we should have the right to defend our property. But the courts have ruled that any use of force must be “objectively reasonable.” It is unreasonable to kill a person over the attempted theft of a $16 hatchet.
Now, if the shoplifter were attempting to use that stolen hatchet to kill someone, then the game changes. But because we are the good guys, our actions must be in reaction to a deadly threat. That means we have to keep our distance and wait to see such a threat. If the threat does not materialize, you can’t use force.
You may disagree with this, but you will be voicing that disagreement to a judge and jury. We, as responsibly armed Americans, cannot be mistaken in our deadly force decision-making. We must do the right thing. Using deadly force to stop shoplifting is not the right thing. Know the laws of your jurisdiction. Reserve deadly force as the final option in your personal-protection plan.
Is Someone Trying to Kill You?
This is the overriding question in the use of deadly force. Do you reasonably believe that someone is trying to kill you? Can you articulate this reasonable belief to other reasonable people? Would those people with the same information you had do the same thing? These are the pivotal questions in determining if deadly force is justified.
__________________
Here is the listings of ALL New Mexico Car Events Including Route 66 Anniversary
https://www.tamparacing.com/forums/t...ar-events.html
Top Car Club Meetings? Click a city
Got a video? Email it to Bobfixesitup@yahoo.com
________________________________________________
Keystone Motor Club (Founded 2012)... Free car show Every 3rd Saturday, newsletter is
https://www.tamparacing.com/forums/e...-car-club.html
Keystone picture gallery is here:
https://carstoshow.com/eventdetails.aspx?eventid=93202
Veterans and Friends on First Saturday...Some pictures....
https://carstoshow.com/registerevent...eventid=102331
Port Richey Rod Run at Coast Buick GMC
https://carstoshow.com/registerevent.aspx?eventid=99114
50's Diner US19.... A Florida Attraction.
1730 US-19, Holiday Fl 34691 click: https://www.tamparacing.com/forums/t...acing.html CHRA sanctioned cruise-in.
Cruise-In; Free; Every Saturday 5-8PM plus 10% off the whole menu to cruisers
50's Diner pictures are here: https://carstoshow.com/eventdetails.aspx?eventid=93194
All Cars Every 2nd Saturday Free Breakfast: Since 2015 and more. click: https://www.tamparacing.com/forums/e...ast-tampa.html
Tampa Racing.com covers the Tampa car scene and supports many fund raisers, worthy causes and events that enrich our community. We hope you enjoy them all.
What do I do? ---- on-site *Aftermarket* spring/suspension installations --- on-site impact wrenching---street lowering with your own stock springs...........True Bi-xenon HID projector headlight conversions........ Much more at Bob's Garage!
https://www.tamparacing.com/forums/b...ontact-us.html
https://www.tamparacing.com/forums/b...e-senor-honda/
Here is the listings of ALL New Mexico Car Events Including Route 66 Anniversary
https://www.tamparacing.com/forums/t...ar-events.html
Top Car Club Meetings? Click a city
Got a video? Email it to Bobfixesitup@yahoo.com
________________________________________________
Keystone Motor Club (Founded 2012)... Free car show Every 3rd Saturday, newsletter is
https://www.tamparacing.com/forums/e...-car-club.html
Keystone picture gallery is here:
https://carstoshow.com/eventdetails.aspx?eventid=93202
Veterans and Friends on First Saturday...Some pictures....
https://carstoshow.com/registerevent...eventid=102331
Port Richey Rod Run at Coast Buick GMC
https://carstoshow.com/registerevent.aspx?eventid=99114
50's Diner US19.... A Florida Attraction.
1730 US-19, Holiday Fl 34691 click: https://www.tamparacing.com/forums/t...acing.html CHRA sanctioned cruise-in.
Cruise-In; Free; Every Saturday 5-8PM plus 10% off the whole menu to cruisers
50's Diner pictures are here: https://carstoshow.com/eventdetails.aspx?eventid=93194
All Cars Every 2nd Saturday Free Breakfast: Since 2015 and more. click: https://www.tamparacing.com/forums/e...ast-tampa.html
Tampa Racing.com covers the Tampa car scene and supports many fund raisers, worthy causes and events that enrich our community. We hope you enjoy them all.
What do I do? ---- on-site *Aftermarket* spring/suspension installations --- on-site impact wrenching---street lowering with your own stock springs...........True Bi-xenon HID projector headlight conversions........ Much more at Bob's Garage!
https://www.tamparacing.com/forums/b...ontact-us.html
https://www.tamparacing.com/forums/b...e-senor-honda/
Last edited by senor honda; Nov 14, 2018 at 07:01 PM.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post



