Scientific question about gas consumption.
Originally Posted by Jeremy2792
Now, which action takes more gas?
-Driving in a high gear, but giving the engine full throttle?
-Driving in a low gear, but giving the engine little throttle, resulting in high RPM's.
So which burns more gas? Pedal to the floor, or high RPM's?
-Driving in a high gear, but giving the engine full throttle?
-Driving in a low gear, but giving the engine little throttle, resulting in high RPM's.
So which burns more gas? Pedal to the floor, or high RPM's?
Fuel use is directly related to load place on an engine, Particuarly in an EFI controlled engine, Higher the load=low vacum=higher injector pulse width.(pulse width is also controlled by throttle position, TPS sensor)
At higher RPM with little throttle, yes the injector must cycle more than at a lower RPM, but the pulse width is much lower. (I am assuming just cruising, and not a WOT blast. )
So if you are going 40 mph in say first gear the RPMs are at ,say 8000 and the throttle is only open a fraction. High vacumn and very little fuel is needed to maintain this. But Go the same speed in 6th gear with the RPMs very low and the throttle wide or almost wide open is going to create low or no vacumn (higher load) with will raise the injector pulse width and use more fuel.
Here are a couple other examples.
*Copied from another site*
1- How Engines Use Gas
When you press your
gas pedal, your gas consumption goes up, right? Many people believe
the gas pedal is connected to the fuel pump somehow, but this is
technically incorrect. Instead, the gas pedal simply opens a valve
called the throttle. All this valve does is to allow air into the
engine. The more open it is, the more air enters. So, the term "gas
pedal" is really a misnomer...it's more of an "air pedal". Anyhow, as
the air entering your engine changes, sensors pick up this info on the
fly and adjust your engine gas intake electronically. In older cars,
this was done through a carburator, a rather ingenious device. This
means simply - the further you push your gas pedal down, the more gas
you burn. It does not matter what gear you're in; how fast your
engine is revving, or really anything else. Gas pedal goes down; gas
cunsumption goes up.
#2
Any engine is at its most efficient, when its RPM is HIGH, and
the load on it is LOW. When you are in a high gear, the load on the
engine is greater, and a slight up hill can easily reduce the RPM,
meaning that there is a greater load on the engine. By shifting down a
gear at that moment, you will effectively reduce the load on the
engine, and the RPM is able to come backup. Yet you have not pressed
the accelerator down any further, thus your fuel (energy) consumption
is still constant.
Originally Posted by Dragin
Any engine is at its most efficient, when its RPM is HIGH, and
the load on it is LOW. When you are in a high gear, the load on the
engine is greater, and a slight up hill can easily reduce the RPM,
meaning that there is a greater load on the engine. By shifting down a
gear at that moment, you will effectively reduce the load on the
engine, and the RPM is able to come backup. Yet you have not pressed
the accelerator down any further, thus your fuel (energy) consumption
is still constant.
the load on it is LOW. When you are in a high gear, the load on the
engine is greater, and a slight up hill can easily reduce the RPM,
meaning that there is a greater load on the engine. By shifting down a
gear at that moment, you will effectively reduce the load on the
engine, and the RPM is able to come backup. Yet you have not pressed
the accelerator down any further, thus your fuel (energy) consumption
is still constant.
Also, higher RPM = higher vacuum. In a carbureted engine, that's going to suck more fuel, probably through the lager main jets vs. through the smaller, more fuel efficient pilot jets. In a fuel injection car, your MAF is going to sense more air or you MAP is going to sense less manifold pressure, and provide the car with more gasoline to compensate for the RPM.
Engines generate more power at higher RPMs, but are certainly not most fuel efficient at high R. My 307 cubic inch Cadillac motor sits at ~1000 RPM all day with its low gearing and gets the same mileage as a V6 and some I4 motors that run higher RPMs.
Originally Posted by TheShow50h
ok, average joe can get confused at this point.
Lower octane=more power if you're not pinging/detonating.
Lower octane=more power if you're not pinging/detonating.
Originally Posted by Frankie
Also, higher RPM = higher vacuum. In a carbureted engine, that's going to suck more fuel, probably through the lager main jets vs. through the smaller, more fuel efficient pilot jets. In a fuel injection car, your MAF is going to sense more air or you MAP is going to sense less manifold pressure, and provide the car with more gasoline to compensate for the RPM.
Engines generate more power at higher RPMs, but are certainly not most fuel efficient at high R. My 307 cubic inch Cadillac motor sits at ~1000 RPM all day with its low gearing and gets the same mileage as a V6 and some I4 motors that run higher RPMs.
Engines generate more power at higher RPMs, but are certainly not most fuel efficient at high R. My 307 cubic inch Cadillac motor sits at ~1000 RPM all day with its low gearing and gets the same mileage as a V6 and some I4 motors that run higher RPMs.
A carb is going to be the same, Its not going to suck the fuel past butterflies that are not open very far, specially if its a 4 barrel. Also look at the power valve, which is vacumn operated, it open allowing more fuel in when vacumn reaches a certain point, Ie 6.5 inches which most Holleys, Demons Etc come with out of the box, So at a higher vacumn it remains shut.
Another way to show this is a car that has a A/F ratio gauge, At higher RPMs with little throttle the A/F will read higher, 12.1 and higher, Being at wide openthrottle at lower rpm, the A/F gauge will be alot richer. 11.0 down.
I have no idea what in the world you guys are talking about
__________________
http://www.woundedwarriorproject.org
http://www.woundedwarriorproject.org
One of the consequences of such notions as "entitlements" is that people who have contributed nothing to society feel that society owes them something, apparently just for being nice enough to grace us with their presence.”
Thomas Sowell (American Writer and Economist, b.1930)
Thomas Sowell (American Writer and Economist, b.1930)
Originally Posted by Frankie
If engines were most fuel efficient at higher RPM, we'd have no reason for transmissions. At higher RPM, even though you have not introduced any additional air, you're introduced additional RPMs. In an 4 stroke engine, you always fire on the ignition stroke and always intake on the intake stroke. You need fuel to do both
.
.
Just because you have more RPMs does not mean you need more fuel, An engine is still just an air pump, Example most modern cars will shut the fuel injectors off all together under decaleration regardless of what RPM the motor is at. Although thats not really pertanaint to the questions he posted.
Originally Posted by Dragin
Just because you have more RPMs does not mean you need more fuel, An engine is still just an air pump, Example most modern cars will shut the fuel injectors off all together under decaleration regardless of what RPM the motor is at. Although thats not really pertanaint to the questions he posted.
Think about a garden hose. It's always open the same amount, but if you only give it so much pressure, by turning the spout on halfway for example, only so much water comes out. The higher pressure the water, the more water is going to come out of the same hole. Same goes for air sneaking past a slightly open butterfly. When you have more pressure coming in, due to a pressure drop in the intake manifold, you're going to be able to squeeze more air in.
When you WOT an engine, do you think it gets maximum air instantly? Nope. You've gotta wait for the RPM's to build up before it realy starts to max out the throughput of that venturi. That's why carbs have accelerator pumps
Originally Posted by Frankie
If we're talking about the same exact engine, if you have more RPMs, you're going to use more fuel. The vacuum differential between the pressure in the manifold and the outside pressure changes based on RPM. With more RPM, you'll see less pressure in the manifold, thus the engine is going to suck harder and use more fuel. That fuel is gonna come from either the jets in the carb or the fuel injectors, but it's still gonna come out. You can't raise RPM without consuming more fuel than at low RPM.
Think about a garden hose. It's always open the same amount, but if you only give it so much pressure, by turning the spout on halfway for example, only so much water comes out. The higher pressure the water, the more water is going to come out of the same hole. Same goes for air sneaking past a slightly open butterfly. When you have more pressure coming in, due to a pressure drop in the intake manifold, you're going to be able to squeeze more air in.
When you WOT an engine, do you think it gets maximum air instantly? Nope. You've gotta wait for the RPM's to build up before it realy starts to max out the throughput of that venturi. That's why carbs have accelerator pumps
Think about a garden hose. It's always open the same amount, but if you only give it so much pressure, by turning the spout on halfway for example, only so much water comes out. The higher pressure the water, the more water is going to come out of the same hole. Same goes for air sneaking past a slightly open butterfly. When you have more pressure coming in, due to a pressure drop in the intake manifold, you're going to be able to squeeze more air in.
When you WOT an engine, do you think it gets maximum air instantly? Nope. You've gotta wait for the RPM's to build up before it realy starts to max out the throughput of that venturi. That's why carbs have accelerator pumps

__________________
-TK
If you can Turn you are not going Fast Enough!
-TK
If you can Turn you are not going Fast Enough!
Originally Posted by Raybo
I'm not a loser, I'm just incarcerated.
Originally Posted by Treysdad
Tell me about it. Sometimes i get this abrasion just under the head, liek a friction rash. All day it will feel like there is a Mexican midget in my boxers licking it with a cats tongue.
I'm lazy and didn't read any previous posts, but anywho.... I've always wondered the same thing as you are asking. I have a little module in my racecar that shows the injector pulse lengths in realtime and when you are at high rpm but just holding partial throttle, the injector pulse length is short as all hell, but at low rpms, to get it to maitain a steady speed you have to give it a lot more throttle and therefore the injector pulse length and way longer. I guess it just depends where the motor is comfortable and happy. Oddly, my truck will get about the same mpg at 75ish as it does at 65ish even though the revs are higher and there is more wind resistance, because the motor is happy where its at and I'm not using as much maintnance throttle.
Oh yeah, I thought that the higher the octane number, the smoother the burn. Smooth means less violent, and therefore a less violent burn will result in more knock-resistance.
Oh yeah, I thought that the higher the octane number, the smoother the burn. Smooth means less violent, and therefore a less violent burn will result in more knock-resistance.
__________________
R.I.P. - Jason Harrill - 6/12/06
"Well, here's the thing".....you will be missed.
R.I.P. - Jason Harrill - 6/12/06
"Well, here's the thing".....you will be missed.


