I had the same problem about 2 months ago. I didnt want to spend 200+ (thats what my friend pays with his mustang from progressive) a month because im 17. I went with direct general/florida no fault because it's the cheapest and i just got the basics. I pay about 94 dollars a month or 1,000 a year being a teenager with about a year of driving experience.

Yeah i know i have the possibility of getting sued if i mess up, but im not rich and just want to be legal.

BTW car is 96 Ford Probe GT. You would prob be the same price or less.

Hope it helps you.