Arguing over .5" of wheel, you're just running your mouth, to run it, and still have yet to provide some sort of actual backup for it.

9.5" wheel up front with a 235mm tire, and 10.5" rear with 255mm works just fine, there are other reasons for running wider fenders and low offset other than to just fit the biggest rim you can in there to impress your friends, i'd explain, but i'd rather leave you that much less informed.