I notice all of the H/A owners in here favor the S2K... but most haven't even driven an SRT-4 yet they bash on it. I always love haters.
Anywho, I've had my SRT4 for about 3 yrs now and its been very reliable. Dynoed 372whp/387wtq, probably alittle more now that I added a few things. Its my daily driver.
I like S2K's... hardtop of course is how I would want one if I were to have one. But at the end of the day its a Honda which pretty much guarantees it will probably get stolen or broken into. Do you want to buy a car that on top you need to equip with (2) alarms and Lo-Jack

. Seriously, I wouldn't mind driving a Honda but then again I wouldn't want to always be worrying about will I see my Honda tomorrow when I wake up or will it still be out there in the parking lot when I get off of work.
OP its your choice, don't let it rest on the TR community making the decision for you. 80% of this community are H/A owners... so you will get an unjust favoring
But if your still unsure after reading these pages of posts. I'd say do what ozzy1 said to do. Go test drive both.