This is a personal decision. We are not you and we will not be the ones making the payment and driving the car. Our life situations are different which means our vehicle choice may not be the same. I do not like the fit and have always loved the s2k but at the same time you just stated you liked the body style of the fit. If practical is what you need then get the fit...if not then get the s2k...just remember the fit has 4 seats and a semi trunk area...the s2k has 2 seat and almost no trunk area. The s2k is a toy...don't expect to use it to transport kids to and from soccer practice or to take your wife and her mom and dad out for dinner. Get my point?