You did not answer the questions posted. Having said that, I own an A4 (GLI-ish) and a MKV GTI. GTI wind hands down. They are both cool but having the same engine, the GTI is faster because it weighs less. GTI hauls more cargo. And if you want a MKV you can get a DSG tranny. Fastest shifting awesomest tranny ever. Destroys manuals all day long and if you have launch control you are in heaven.