I used a pry-bar to try to get it out. Thats the way to do it usually, I had the tranny out and everything, beating on it with a mallet. prying it. Nothing. Wouldnt budge. The other side came out, this one was stuck. I put it all back together, but I was just curious on this, cause I have never had a shaft get stuck. Wondering if the pin got caught up inside.