Ok an update, I talked to tom about specific tires. I think from what some others have suggested that I'm going with Metzler M3's. He quoted me 115 for the rear and 90 for the front (mounted free) which is indeed cheap.

The issue now is another shop offered to get me the tires for 30 bucks more than what RTM has quoted me also mounted and balanced for free. So...I don't really feel like their doing me much of a favor now. I'll call Tom again tomorrow and let him know the situation and see what he says.

What do you all think of that?