1985 Toyota Corolla
Love:
1. Best of 36.14 MPG (33 average)
2. I actually profited about $500 immediately just by buying it (insurance and credit card rebate)
3. I'm the 2nd owner.

Hate:
1. Ugly
2. Despite incredible reliability, it does have 200K miles, and I just never know when it's gonna give up.
3. ALMOST tempted to mod/paint it.