I'm going through the exact same thing except it was a hit and run in a parking lot while my car was parked.destroyed my bumper on the pass side and messed up the quarter panel.got quotes from two different places:

1)Driven Concepts:$1,289
2)Carsmetics:$879

both included new oem bumper,fitting of the bumper,prep and painting of the bumper,pulling out the dent in the quarter panel,sanding and finishing the quarter panel before painting,painting of the quarter panel,and polish.

I ended up going with carsmetics because they have a 100% color match garuntee(sp?).and they only have to keep it 2-3 days instead of dc's 5-7 days.