Just one of each right? I would most likely say that the JL W7 are the better of the two. But I tell you what I have some two 12inch 86120DVC's and they hit hard as hell. I can't put the windows up when I play them because I will get a headache (cause of the pressure). I didn't have the money for the W7's so I had to buy the eclipses. It's ok though cause I am totally satisfied.