Wow,
From an outsider know one can really say anything. Sounds like you should just give him the money and take the loss. End it there, and I also commend you for coming on here and speaking your words. I don't think there is really any reason to beat someone up over this, as this is not high school. I was ripped by Slow Boy Racing and as much as I tried there is nothing they will do to give me my money back.
I say do this like two adults and work it out with out anyone beating anyone up. Even $200 in not worth jail time. But I am still on the side of saying just give him his money back and the p28 and call it a day. That is not a big amount of money and everyone can just forget about it and move on. Maybe Cj can take down the sig so the new people don't see this.
Well good luck with what ever you guys do...................
__________________
Cburke.industries.
Custom suspension bars, metal fabrication.