There isn't anything wrong with Eagle parts if you aren't going to be pushing the limits of your engine to the edge and beyond.

Hell, even if you are, we have had two engines do very well with Eagle components. One was a SBF (Eagle 4340 crank, Eagle H-beam rods and Venolia pistons) that went 5.70's at Sunshine running at over 3200 pounds with a single fogger. This car was still driven on the street from time to time. The second was a BBC (Eagle 4340 crank, Eagle H-beam rods, Venolia pistons) that went 5.30's at Sunshine also at over 3200 pounds and a single fogger.

For the money, and as long as the parts are within spec when you check them, I think Eagle parts aren't too bad of a choice.