There was a piece of the inner lip that got chipped, the tire shop said the tire was just fine...I even offered to sell him a set of brand new nittos 315/35/17s for the same price in an act of kindness. He could have gotten even better tires for his trouble. Both goodyear tires are fine, actually i sold them and they are on another car right now with no issues. But i guess if you complain about 15 bucks in gas and you were going to get almost 600 bucks in tires for 250, thats just life...goodluck..